Wednesday, April 26, 2006

Paper blathering

Need to beg indulgences, but I've got a paper I need to write that isn't cooperating. Sometimes if I discuss it "out loud" it'll help get things flowing. Right now, I'm not entirely sure what my point is.

The paper began as a discussion of mathematical beauty, how that maps into musical beauty, what the role of music theory is in all of this, and how mathematicians and music theorists really don't mean "beauty," but something more like "enlightenment." This didn't pan out because mathematicians don't do the kind of metatheorizing that music theorists do. Or if they do have metadiscussions, it's not in terminology I can understand.

So I gravitated towards discussing music as experience and either recapturing (music theory) or encapsulating (composition) that. Now people whose writings I like tend to not draw a fine distinction between composition and music theory. I think both have similar goals, but I'm not hugely convinced that the experience of doing one or the other is similar.

Then I happened upon this quote from Benjamin Boretz:

Transcendence, then is not at all restricted to ecstasy, devouring passion, undifferentiated oneness with the universe, all-suffusing peacefulness, blinding sensation--Precise, vivid, specific, as experiential quality, the total replacement of the state of normal consciousness with a distinct state. Terrified of so much significance--that is, so much distinctness of identity in one's own experience as to be utterly isolated from the external world as a consequence of the most vivid act of experiencing it--people seek objectivity in and about their music. They invent an abstract ontology of qualities which are intersubjective--perceivable and denotable--on the order of green--pitch, say--and then talk about music as the composition of these qualities; sometimes they try to teach themselves, or are even taught by others, to actually hear music in this countersubjective flat empirical way, as if it were like discourse in its neutral rhetorical transparency. (("starting now from here,...") three consecutive occasions of sociomusical reflection)
In my mind, the act of "doing" music, whether theorizing or composing, is something similar to contemplation. Elsewhere, I've discussed how composition is more like "infused contemplation," and I'm wondering if music theorizing is more like dark contemplation. What do you have, when the experience is taken away? There's a faint trace of it in re-representation or performance of music, but it's never the same as the experience which produced it. Or the experience of producing it.

I'm the last person on the planet to discount the role of experience and transcendence in art. However, I think there's a very real trap to fall into in the experiential model of music theory. If music is to produce some sort of experience or transcendence, then what's to keep it from becoming some sort of drug? If music becomes a way to program experience, what's to keep it from losing significance and power? It's precisely because of the "so much distinctness of identity in one's own experience" that there needs to be some other thing to balance it.

If infused contemplation is the original event which fuels the contemplative life, dark contemplation is what keeps contemplatives honest. The kind of transcendence Boretz is speaking of certainly isn't infused contemplation. It's a different kind of transcendence that I think is more like dark contemplation. And that's where I am, at the moment.

Monday, April 24, 2006

What I learned this weekend:

  • The people who really matter will stand out in difficult times when the proverbial excrement hits the fan.
  • There are some things worth fighting for, as cheesy as it sounds.
  • As much as I whine, complain, and grouse about academia, it's still a far cry better than the chance of not finishing.
  • I put entirely too much self-worth into a piece of paper that says "DMA."
  • Sometimes it takes something big happening to make one realize what's really important.


Thursday, April 20, 2006

Most video games don't make a secret of their politics. America's Army is the most obvious--if not overly clever--example of this. Your average martial-themed strategy game post-9/11 has some sort of terrorist cell, usually Middle Easternish. (Poor Edward Said is probably spinning in his grave.)

Other games have a more hidden political agenda. For instance, a friend quipped that Dark Age of Camelot's latest expansion, "Darkness Rising," should've been called "Jihad Rising." (One is called upon by the king of one's realm to defend against an uprising from a demonic cult.) While I seriously doubt Mythic was thinking about 9/11, the Zeitgeist is there, and it's one which is in the forefront of people's minds. I think video games provide some sort of power over a situation we might not have a lot of control over. As such, they're a way to constructively work out one's feelings and frustrations. In DAoC, I'm sure it's no accident that a truly benevolent king is asking heroes to defend against a present and visible threat; however, the WMD's clearly exist in DAoC in the form of very ugly demons in the Circle of Five dungeons.

I promised myself that I'd purchase the expansion to City of Heroes once my exams were over. I never got around to it, so a friend graciously sent a gift certificate to Amazon for it. So I've been playing City of Villains lately. I must admit. It's fun to be a bad guy. The game is structured almost identically to City of Heroes, except for newspaper missions (a welcome addition.) At first, I didn't know how I would feel playing a villain. City of Heroes fits in with my ethics, and I thought that City of Villains would give people an excuse to run around and be assholes. It turns out I find myself questioning my actions in City of Heroes way more than I do in City of Villains.

First, the setting: Paragon City, Rhode Island. This is the area where the heroes play. It's mostly new, clean (except for the "working class" areas, but they look old, not necessarily skeevy). Part of the newness has to do with the fact that the city was invaded and almost destroyed by a race of aliens called the Rikti. (This happened towards the end of the open beta, I'm told.) The game's "present" takes place after the reconstruction of Paragon City.

And then we have the Rogue Islands. They are older than Paragon City, appear to be untouched by the Rikti wars (there are cobblestone streets and true gothic buildings, unlike neo-gothic skyscrapers in Paragon City). Streets wind, and there's obvious blight and disrepair. Most of the areas I've seen so far are areas with "character," as a Craigslist landlord would put it.

So when I began playing CoV, my character was rescued by a crime syndicate in the Rogue Islands, Arachnos. A comment made by an NPC put an inkling in the back of my head that things might not be as they seem in Paragon City. She said that in the Rogue Islands, one has complete freedom.

Of course, it's complete chaos as far as social order goes. Your missions are assassinations, heists, and the like. (I'm surprised anyone wealthy goes to Larry's Tiki Lounge anymore, with as many heists as I pulled there on Mercy Island while levelling.) There is nothing opaque about one's motivations as a villain: your bottom line and infamy.

So tonight as my chill time, I was playing in Paragon City for a change of pace. My hero entered the server, and I became sick to my stomach. My first sight was a large billboard, proclaiming that Earth was for humans. Another billboard says that "they" are still among us, and to report any strange activity. I've seen these billboards hundreds of times since I started playing the game last summer, but the context had radically shifted.

In CoV, there is no discrimination as to who might be an antagonist. In CoH, the antagonists are those who are different, changed, and not part of mainstream society. One gang, "The Lost," is comprised of homeless people being changed into Rikti. Another gang, "The Trolls," are a Superdyne addicts
(the drug of choice in Paragon city) physically altered into a subhuman race. The Tsoo are a vaguely Asian gang. (There goes poor Said again.) In short, anyone "different" is a potential antagonist. That the antagonists' powers resemble the heroes' powers is no accident.

There's something eerily Orwellian and totalitarian about Paragon City, with it's manicured lawns and grid-construction streets. Heroes are kept in check by their service to the State. Sure, the Arachnos billboards in the Rogue Islands provide propaganda, but their messages are couched in potentiality: one has the ability to better one's situation through the organization. Granted, my ninja mastermind is only level 10. But it'll be interesting to see if there are any other context shifts, the further I get.

On another friend's blog, someone remarked, "We would do well to remember that only as a living tradition are we the sacrament of salvation." It was one of those comments that hit me in the gut, in a good way, and made me hopeful. He was speaking of the Catholic Church and tendencies towards unthinking legalism that seem to be popular among the twentysomethings, but it dawned on me that he could be speaking about what it is to be a composer.

All composers are part of a living tradition. The common notion about composers is that they operate in some mythical, romantic past, and that every piece they make is some sort of masterwork. (Whether or not the concept of a "masterwork" exists, is another blog entry for another time.) But popular notion aside, at any given moment, there are people out there (still breathing), who're writing music. The act of composition can be seen as a kind of repetition. And like the earlier post on repetition, there is a danger of being trapped in either slavery or rehearsal.

Since we have almost a thousand years worth of tradition, it's easy to become enslaved to it. The model of music theory is one of rules and empiricisms (think basic theory), and, to an extent, part of the legalistic model of music theory is used to teach composition. In it, a student must learn certain stylistic rules of different historical periods, and then they make music based upon it. Composition becomes like part-writing or counterpoint exercises. They might make some good music this way, but they're trapped to a bunch of rules, which really don't exist. The joy of creation becomes a part-time job.

It would be wrong to say that music theory is only the analytical material one would find in a first or second-year theory text; and it is criminal to teach composition along these ways. Outside of a first or second year theory class, nobody cares whether or not you resolve chords, if you use chords at all, or if you do a perfect sonata form. The only thing that matters is the piece, itself. The degree to which the composer conformed to some stylistic practice is secondary.

The other type of enslavement is when everything is new. In this type of slavery, the composer-to-be is obsessed with only producing "new" things. They are in the process of perfecting their "art," which means obsessing over that which hasn't been done previously. They have little concern for those who came before, and every work they produce must be one which breaks these connections. People in this extreme can also make good music, but there is the danger of becoming imprisoned in one's own ego.

I don't write music in a vaccuum. I studied with various people, who studied with various people. I listen to music. There are sounds all around me, and I can't write in an anechoic chamber. I can't deny that they are a part of me when I write, so there will be elements of other people in my music. Another joy of composition comes when I realize that these people are so a part of me that they flow into what I do unthinkingly.

It's only when I'm aware of my roots and conscious of what possibilities are out there that I'm free to be the composer I'm meant to be. It's the "un-self-ish"ly opening towards some larger and unconfined end that is what it means to be part of a living tradition. If my future were determined by some past tradition, I'd be just as enslaved as if every possibility were open. Without some final cause, which retains some element of mystery, I become trapped in either extreme.

Friday, April 14, 2006

Those of you who know me from elsewhere should know by now that I don't like René Girard. Not him, personally, since I'm sure he's a perfectly nice human being; but his writings annoy me to no end, especially Violence and the Sacred, which has some currency among cultural theorists. In a nutshell, in order to quell violence, a sacrificial victim (surrogate) has to be killed and then contemplated; but in the act of killing the surrogate, violence can be mistaken for the sacrificial act, throwing more violence into the system. And the more the community contemplates the sacrificial victim, the more they desire it, also creating more strife. (Of course, this is an oversimplification.) The reference to the Eucharist is obvious.

His writings have their uses in cultural theory, and he often gets used to describe issues of desire, consumer vs. mass culture, a framework for discussing the sacred without referencing any one particular religion, and the like. In particular, the expression of creativity can be seen as a violent act:

I see every music-doing act by a socialized person as an act having something for or against me; you doing something for or against you. At the very least, I need to articulate my thoughts out loud among you, to put my music sound out there where others are, to disseminate my articulations of word ideas and music ideas, so that there will be some resonance of my reality, or my ontology, for me to hear coming back at me from within the world I inhabit, too, not just the resonances of everyone else's, or some generalized resonance of everyone's. (Benjamin Boretz, "Interface V. The InnerStudio (Strategies for Retrieving Reality in Music Experience and Practice.")

The notion that I'm somehow imposing myself upon an audience is something I wrestle with. Where is your place, if you know you're vocation is in some form of the contemplative life, which is by definition hidden and reserved, but also part of the same vocation is, by necessity, extroverted? Some composers don't have a problem with assaulting the audience with themselves. What Boretz is trying to get at is the relevance of creativity, and how it might be used to reconcile the "me-against-you" danger of composition and creativity. Within his essay, the consideration of the Other is what wards against this danger.

Part of what pisses me off the most (even more than his Paleolithic views on gender role) about Girard's book is his take on the sacrificial act. In his worldview, we don't have a choice--we're compelled by the very thing which brings us peace to use it against other people. In his world, every act of creativity is an act of violence against someone else. It doesn't matter if you're the one being sacrificed, or the one drawing the blade over the victim's throat. But the way out of his feedback cycle of violence is to not play along. From Wednesday's (the Wednesday after Passion Sunday) Office of Readings:

"What does it mean to sit at this table if not to approach it with humility? What does it mean to observe carefully what is set before you if not to meditate devoutly on so great a gift? What does it mean to stretch out one's hand, knowing that one must provide the same kind of meal oneself, if not what I have just said: as Christ laid down his life for us, so we in our turn ought to lay down our lives for our brothers? This is what the apostle Paul said: Christ suffered for us, leaving us an example, that we might follow in his footsteps.
This is what is meant by providing "the same kind of meal." This is what the blessed martyrs did with such burning love. If we are to give true meaning to our celebration of their memorials, to our approaching the Lord's table in the very banquet at which they were fed, we must, like them, provide "the same kind of meal." (From a treatise on John by St. Augustine.)
Girard forgot a four-letter word from his catechism: love. It's not enough to blindly follow along with the herd in the sacrifice. Out of love, by participating in it, it means becoming it. or put another way by a Dominican who would routinely visit my old parish, to participate in the Eucharist is to break the bread of one's own life.

Similarly to Boretz's notion, the Other is my hope. If I exert what might be called "myself" in a piece of music, I'm offering myself, out of love, to the Other. If my life, and everything coming out of it, becomes a reflection of the Eucharist, how can I cause violence to the Other?

Monday, April 10, 2006

There's another line in another article by John Rahn (If you haven't guessed I like his writings):

There is a positive joy in perceiving a flawlessly intricate musical structure, one which leads the mind to startling discoveries as it is unfolded, offering depths upon depths into which we peer, within which we play, but which are never exhausted, never leave us low and dry.
This is not the flash of a Richard Strauss, not the meretricious craftsmanship of the mere technician, unconnected to the wellsprings of his human existence; it is, rather, the kind of craftsmanship that apes the divine, or from which the notion of divine creation is extrapolated. ("What is Valuable in Art, and Can Music Still Achieve it?")
A bit of backstory...I started out my composerly life, as do many others, as a performing musician. My teachers played in the orchestra near where I grew up, they played studio gigs in the area, and when I entered college,it was thought I'd follow in their footsteps. That's all I knew. A high school orchestra director routinely quipped that art and fifty cents would get you a cup of coffee.

I'm not here to debate commercial/entertainment music and "high" art. My inner ethnoid tells me that both have their places (I do write about video game soundtracks, after all). Instead, I'd like to describe something more personal, namely why I'm in the field I am, and why I can't be a part of the commercial musician's world. The last sentence of Rahn's passage sums it up for me. I'm devoted to a kind of creation,"from which the notion of divine creation is extrapolated."

But when I was facing a lifetime of being in the "business" of music, studio gigs, wedding parties, and the like, the feeling of being "stuck" in the situation was oppressive. I was just begining to discover that I could write music, and it was (and is) something I barely understood, but knew that this was something special, which if I chose to accept it would mean a radical repositioning of my life. It also offered the prospect of something else.

I don't know where I'm going. When I started grad school, I had no idea that other people like me--composers--existed. The more I come into contact with it, the less I understand about the ability to write music. But I can't help but be humbled--and a little frightened--of the chance to peer into the kind of creation which Rahn describes. It's a kind of creation which changes me as much as the thing I'm writing.

Monday, April 03, 2006

"A morte perpetua, libera nos, Domine." (from the Litany of Saints)

There's something powerful about art and the aesthetic experience. It's hard to say anything about it at all, without falling into trivializations and banal metaphors. And even the act of translation from pure experience into language can make the experience seem flat and empty. Yet it's one of the most powerful forces we can experience. It's a life-changing and life-saving moment, when it happens. Remembering such experiences, I find they're no less vivid, for the years separating them.

It's an experience which lifts us out of ourselves, as Merton put it, and points to something greater than we could possibly become otherwise. Infused contemplation, when it comes, is a powerful grace. It's a rare thing, and something not everyone encounters. Those who haven't think that they aren't capable or good enough for it, but like any grace, it isn't our choice when it's given.

"In contrast, what I would like here to call "repetition" is repetition within a larger thing whose telos is not given (as in répétition), but is in the process of being formed. Such subglobal repetition is not répétition because the point is not to perfect (τελεω ) the thing repeated, by accomplishing its telos, but to point beyond the thing repeated to the thing being formed. This is lively because it escapes the dead hand of some prefigured order; like life, it is a process of continual transcendence toward who knows what end. The focus is always forward, un-self-ish, opening away from the current entity in the direction of something larger and unconfined." ("Repetition", John Rahn)
It's relatively easy to become trapped in everyday life and routine, whether imposed from outside or within. There's another name for the lowest order of repetition in Rahn's essay, slavery: acedia, the "noonday demon," and the bane of monastics since the early days in the desert. It's a state of being in which life becomes drudgery, one plodding step after another, and the routines and pressures become oppressive.

The second order is répétition, or rehearsal. In it, there's some sort of final cause, or telos, but it's mired in the fact that the telos is fixed and unchanging, another kind of slavery, perhaps less insidious than the first.

The third order, repetition, is a continual transformation towards an unknown end. But this isn't plunging into chaos, rather it's an unfolding into something greater. It's this "opening away from the current entity in the direction of something larger and unconfined" that makes the aesthetic experience what it is.

For some, infused contemplation comes as a result of a period of overwhelming darkness, aceida, or some other "dark night." People have moments where they're awestruck at something, but the difference between these little moments and the life-changing one is one of magnitude. It's not that this experience makes the situation magically better--in the writings of the visionaries and other contemplatives, their lives often get worse afterwards--but rather that one's awareness is expanded out of itself towards some other purpose, one hidden, but larger than the situation one finds oneself mired in.

When it happens, we're faced with a choice: either to accept the gift of infused contemplation, and all the trials which come with it, or to remain in what came before. One kind of death happens with its acceptance: we can't be the same people we were before. The experience is often one which heals us, but leaves us changed in its wake. The other choice leads to another kind of death, far worse than anything physical. But saying "yes" to infused contemplation means accepting the moment with one's whole being. It may lead to darker things than we could imagine, but also the hope for something far more than we could ever conceive.

Friday, March 31, 2006

Flogging dead equines

I've had an ongoing debate with my chair about video game violence. His point is that games, while not causing violence, make it more likely to happen, a kind of rehearsal for it. I've argued the opposite. I think violence and video games is one, big red herring, which takes away time from other, more important discourses. I promise this is the last thing I'm saying on the matter.

I have to believe that we aren't a product of our environments. The fact that I've got a choice in the matter is what gets me out of bed in the morning, and helps me to have normal kinds of human interactions. More on this later after an aside.

Aside: one of the most disconcerting things about the Liturgy of Hours is encountering people who've consecrated their lives to peace and contemplation recite or chant some of the cursing psalms. (35, 69, 109 are the three worst) It's difficult to relate the sheer cognitive dissonance of a group of nuns reciting a line from the psalms discussing dashing children's heads against rocks.

I asked a friend of mine, a Benedictine nun, about this when I was in the process of becoming an oblate. Her response was that the violent imagery helps her understand and pray for those who are affected by it. She had an obligation to not shy away from those lines, no matter how repugnant or distasteful, so she could do her job as a contemplative.

Do I have better things I could be doing than going on shooting rampages throughout Liberty City? You can count on it. Is there a better use of my time than engaging other departments on campus in Quake deathmatches? Most definitely.

There are more insidious forms of violence, which never leave a bruise, nor do they find their virtual expression in a cloud of pixelated gore from being hit with a BFG. It's easy to focus upon physical violence because it leaves the most obvious mark. But emotional, spiritual, verbal, and psychological violence is no less harmful, even if the marks are nebulous and can't be objectively proven.

Literature on video game violence would suggest that violence in games may increase violent tendencies. And it's similar to literature on abuse: those who have been abused are more likely to abuse others. Perhaps I'm tempting fate by playing violent video games, since I've got the double-whammy the literature would like me to have.

But I find there's something healing about violent video games. A few years ago, I wouldn't have been able to play Quake against other people. I'm still not overly comfortable with it, but it won't give me nightmares. I've been exposed to a lot of real-world violence, not all of it physical and thankfully none of it sexual, and it isn't remotely similar to that which is found in video games.

If I hide from violence, thinking that it'll make me do violent things, I'm still controlled by it. Those who perpetrated the violence would still have power over me. My indulgences in Quake and Grand Theft Auto are my erect middle finger at them. But there's another reason from not hiding from violence. Girard was wrong: exposure to violence doesn't beget other acts of violence. It can promote empathy. I feel that which I've experienced helps me to feel what others have endured. In a weird way, it feels as if their burden is shared. If I knew that their burden was eased by my old hurts, I'd relive it again.

Monday, March 27, 2006

I don't think it's by accident that universities sprang up around monasteries. If you look hard enough vestiges of it can be seen in architecture (Most campuses have some sort of "quad," which looks suspiciously like a garth, with rows of buildings surrounding it like a cloister), dress (ever compare a traditional monastic habit with the gowns and hoods Ph.Ds wear?), curriculum (trivium, anyone?), the fact that monasteries were libraries and places of learning, and the attitude of life as a process and formation. No matter how distant the beginnings, academics still need to learn a lot from contemplatives.

On the 16th Sunday in Ordinary Time (the period after Pentecost and until the day after the feast of Christ the King), in Year C (so once every 3 years) we get this reading:

In the course of their journey he came to a village, and a woman named Martha welcomed him into her house. She had a sister called Mary, who sat down at the Lord's feet and listened to him speaking. Now Martha, who was distracted with all the serving came to him and said, 'Lord, do you not care that my sister is leaving me to do the serving all by myself? Please tell her to help me.' but the Lord answered, 'Martha, Martha,' he said, 'you worry and fret about so many things, and yet few are needed, indeed only one. It is Mary who has chosen the better part, and it is not to be taken from her.' (Luke 10:38-42, New Jerusalem Bible)

We all know at least one Martha. They're the ones who have their hands in everything, are "team players," are part of every committee, do five things at once, and have no patience for Maries. In the Ivory tower, they're the ones who make every faculty meeting, are on several committees, have at least three papers going at once, and teach a full load consistently. They have little time for anything that doesn't directly add to their CV. The Ivory Tower needs its Marthas, since they're the do-ers. I think most academics have a Martha hidden somewhere inside of them, and certainly grad school forces one into that mindset.

That having been said, I think many of the problems in academia stem from the fact that we're all running around like Marthas with our heads cut off. Burnout happens--whether student or professor--from having too much to do, most of it unavoidable, especially in the days of budget cuts. Interpersonal conflicts happen when burnt out people get sick of being around each other. And the Martha in us all gets resentful when we find a Mary, who isn't a "team player," and appears to be loafing around, doing nothing, while we're distracted with serving.

'You worry and fret about so many things, and yet few are needed, indeed only one.' It's so easy to get wrapped up in the daily minutiae of the grind. The part Mary took for herself may seem to be selfish and lazy, yet it's the part that we most desperately need in the Ivory Tower. The best definition of the contemplative life that I've heard came from one of the Dominicans at my parish: "resting in the embrace of the Divine."

I think we can be better teachers, students, researchers, and academics if we take time for ourselves. The cloister isn't always a physical space, and it isn't always possible. But it's about reserving a part of ourselves and taking the time to refresh the rest of us, "resting in the embrace of the Divine." On first glance, the contemplative life in western monasticism seems overindulgent and impractical. What good are people who pray all day? Why break up a perfectly productive day with the Liturgy of the Hours? But it's this constant drive for productivity and work which is burning out people and hurting them.

In Benedictine monasticism, one's life becomes a continual prayer, with the Liturgy of Hours and the Eucharist being central. The offices are a time to recenter and publicly connect with the central reason for being there, in the first place, and the Eucharist forms the source of all aspects of life.

I'm not saying that there should be public time for prayer in the Ivory Tower, but if academics are to survive this time we're in (which is by no means favorable to higher ed), then they need to consider Mary. It's only by taking their better part, some time to reconnect with who they are and why they're there in the first place, that they can find the strength to keep going. And administrations need to realize that this better part is our right, and not to be taken from us.

Tuesday, March 14, 2006

You know, I almost feel sorry for "Ivan Tribble," a pseudonym of a columnist at the "Chronicle of Higher Education." He wrote two rather scathing critiques of blogging, insinuating that one who desires a job in the Ivory Tower shouldn't blog, but then backpedals, saying that they should be careful about supplying the URL to one's website or blog when applying for a job. The backlash was extreme, even though he does have a good point or two in the second essay. Not that he doesn't have it coming, since blogging is one of the hottest topics in digital literature and in most fields, but he's been flogged enough.

But in the second essay, he does have a point. It's far too easy to get information about a person via google. As my computer security boyfriend reminds me, nothing on the internet is secure, and information is notoriously hard to secure. The only privacy we have is that which we create.

Out of curiosity, I plugged my real name into google. My dopplegangers are into various sports, a real estate agent, and a beer executive. And it turned up a bunch of seemingly-benign information about my person. It turned up some posts I made to a programming language mailing list, a few concert listings, and a schedule of liturgical ministries I'm involved with in my parish.

According to Prof. Tribble, I should be concerned about the last one, since it does give identifying information about my personal life, and is, therefore, suspect. Any employer would find out that I'm a practicing Catholic, Eucharistic minister, and altar server. We aren't far removed from the days of "Catholics need not apply," and while I've never encountered anything but respect from my professors, I've heard a lot of anti-Catholic BS from fellow students. In the days where evangelical Christianity--which isn't overly friendly to Catholicism--is dominant and Catholicism is seen as nothing more than rabid anti-abortion platforms, it isn't an easy thing to be a practicing Catholic and academic. My politics are assumed for me, if one should happen to glance the medal of Our Lady of Guadalupe I normally wear.

But the larger question is one of distance: where is the line between public and private? Is there even such a line anymore? How far should one have to bury one's private life to get a job? What about to hold it? Should an employer have the right to delve into one's personal lives?

Friday, March 10, 2006

In memory of me...

I'm thinking I need to start a piece for a former teacher of mine, who recently passed. It's a strange and difficult thing to be thinking about, since a part of me doesn't want to believe he's dead; another part keeps sending off emails, forgetting; and the other part still hurts. Because of my exams and the headspace required for them, I'm just now coming to terms with it. You find someone dear to you, and you think they're going to be around forever.

There's another loss I'm thinking of lately. Since I'm ABD, the formal composition study I had is ending. I know all relationships eventually end, but it's a bit melancholy. I'm more than capable of making my own decisions, but I miss the debate and fellowship that came from private instruction. But this is the natural order of things. People grow to leave home, and every birth contains within it a death.

These people aren't far away, though. Whenever I compose something, it feels like they're with me and are a part of me. Their presence is no less real and strong, even if they aren't around physically. A Benedictine once described ritual as a kind of prayer you do for others when they're not able, and when the time comes, they do the same for you. I don't see composition as being that much different. I know these people were carrying me, when I couldn't work. Now I'm blessed to be able to do the same.

Wednesday, March 08, 2006

This one is about a cup of tea.

We often go through life not thinking about the effects we have upon others. Sometimes this means taking those around us for granted. It's all too easy to fall into the trap that we mean nothing to those around us, and it's a mindset that's easy to adopt in the Ivory Tower. So much of what we do in grad school is isolated from others, and our colleagues become competitors, especially now, when finances are cut daily for higher education.

I hear and read about other grad students and their relationships to their chairs. Sometimes it's a good one, but it seems like there are so many people out there with broken relationships with their chairs, like so many other relationships.

My chair's someone, with whom I have much in common, but also differences. While there have been metaphorical scrapes and bruises, we tend to get along pretty well. Considering some of the stories out there, I think I'm pretty fortunate to be studying with the person I am.

It would be naive to say that things have been easy. There was a time when we were both pretty burnt out and things were tense. I can't imagine I was too pleasant to be around in the months leading up to my exams, either. Trust doesn't come easily to me, especially when it involves some sort of authority figure, which probably created some tension, as well.

So fast forward to last week. My throat was killing me; my voice was nonexistent; I had the flu; and the soundcard on my computer kept falling out of its PCI slot. I had a bottle of water and hopes that I'd make it through. While I had my head in the bowels of my computer, banging in the soundcard once again, my chair asked if I wanted a cup of tea, since he was getting something. I think it was because of that tea that I made it through the next couple hours of my exams.

On the surface, it seemed like a mundane enough interaction, but when you're sick and nervous as hell, such things take on different proportions. He was doing what anyone with half an ounce of common courtesy would do, but in a larger sense it's also a metaphor of what the student/chair relationship is. It's an unthinking, selfless giving. It doesn't always happen, and it isn't always noticed. But when it does, it becomes a powerful moment.

Wednesday, March 01, 2006

Out from under the pall...

"Receive me, Lord, as you have promised, and I shall live; do not disappoint me in your hope."

I passed. =)

Friday, February 10, 2006

"Do not grant newcomers to the monastic life an easy entry..." (Rule of St. Benedict, 56:1)

In most monasteries, people entering go through some rite. It varies by community, but at the start of their novitiate, they stand in front of the community and are asked, "What do you seek?" The answer goes something like this, "I seek the mercy of God and fellowship in this community." Then usually the budding monastic takes a version of vows, signs some document stating that promise, and then recites the line, "Receive me, Lord, as you have promised, and I shall live; do not disappoint me in your hope." Then other various things happen according to local custom and order, including a blessing from the other community members, a full prostration before them, and some sort of clothing ceremony, if the community wears a habit.

A friend kindly reminded me last night that one's doctoral exams aren't much different than the contemplative life, and it struck me that this is a rite of profession, of sorts. It's not so much the exam, itself, which terrifies me, but failing, rejection, and the disappointment of others. Yet my chair has reminded me, repeatedly, that they want people to pass, and that he wouldn't let me get to this point, if there were no hope, whatsoever. I've also been told that I'm not a unique snowflake in my freaking out.

Said friend also reminded me that this is the first entrance into life as an academic, and that it's designed as a time for me to shine. Ignoring the voice in the back of my head predicting doom, ruin, and failure, this is my first big appearance before the community. In a sense, like the young monastic, this is a sign of my promise to persevere in this life; and my committee's promise is to support me in it, as the novice would receive the support and blessing of his/her community.

But I'm going to be very glad once this is over with.

Sunday, January 29, 2006

An open letter to parents...

Hi, parents. This one's for you. I'll be addressing newbie college students in the future.

By this time, you should be hearing back from college applications. Don't worry. Your kid will get in somewhere. Don't worry about that financial aid thing. It'll eventually work itself out, and it's a lot like buying a car--the first offer might not be the one you wind up signing. But I'm not going to talk about that today.

This is the time you're anticipating, and I'm sure it's a bit scary. Your kid is going to be leaving the house for the Big U. College is unlike any other experience he/she has probably had, and it can also be one of the greatest times of his/her life. Here's the biggest suggestion I can possibly offer: it's your kid's life.

Your kid may decide to switch majors. This is normal and expected. I didn't settle on a major for my BA until my Junior year. What they thought they might like, they may find they hate. They may discover some love of another field that they never knew they'd like. I thought I was going to major in applied music, until I had a severe RSI caused by practicing and rehearsals. You never know what's going to happen, and they need the freedom to discover what and who they are. Just because they share DNA with you doesn't mean that they'll follow in your footsteps, or the footsteps of what you wanted to do. After all, this is the moment you raised them for: to have some sort of independent existence. If you did your job--which I'm sure you did--they'll make good choices and be good people.

Please, please, please, dear God, please refrain from manipulating your kid's class choices by asserting the fact that you're paying for their college. One, go back and read the previous paragraph. Two, consider the effect it will have on your kid. Either they'll defy you and take it anyway, or there's going to be resentment and bad blood. If you don't mind resentment and bad blood, consider what kind of adult relationship you want with your kid. If you don't mind tension and discord, please remind them often of the fact that you're paying for their college. If you want them to have their own life and cherish you, then remember how charity should be given: lovingly and in secret.

As to majoring in something they can get a job in...it was fashionable to double major in computer science when I was an undergrad. People thought that they could always find a gig, if their chosen field didn't pan out. Fast forward 3 years. The dotcom bust happened, and there were a lot of computer science double majors bagging groceries. You never know what the job market is going to do. If your kid majors in something they love, odds are they'll find a way to make it work for them. These days, those who can forge their own way have a better shot at making it.

I know what I'm writing about, because my family doesn't approve of what I study. There was tension throughout my BA; they didn't speak to me much through my MFA; and now there's open hostility. Yeah, if your kid truly loves a discipline and has some talent in it, they'll find a way to do it. It wasn't easy, but I did get into graduate school. What they want to do with their lives may not make sense, and it may seem like they're destined to live in your basement with a degree in a non-lucrative field. But you know what? They'll find a way to live, if they're determined. It's hard to starve in this country, if you're willing to work. Wouldn't you rather share in their success?

Friday, January 27, 2006

You don't start a doctorate if you don't love your field. Passionately, intensely, and deeply. A doctorate is a vocation, of sorts, in the monastic sense of the term, but the conversatio mori is in the pursuit of one's discipline.

No matter the debate on degree and grade inflation, getting a doctorate is hard work. We don't just sit on our asses all day long and think lofty thoughts. Most of us work full-time, come home and then pour over our research. We don't get evenings and weekends off. We don't get breaks for holidays. Some of us have children to care for, or significant others to pay attention to. Our opus Dei is the never-ending stream of research, and our lectio divina is the latest article out of our discipline's journal.

But more importantly than research, our job is one of witness. And I don't mean the kind of browbeat-the-other-into-submission that TV evangelists mean by the word "witness." I'm talking about a kind of sacred attention to the other. It's a kind of attention where the boundaries between teacher and student dissolve. We teach with our lives.

Sometimes the seed takes, sometimes it doesn't. All the whining and wrangling over tenths of grade points somehow becomes worth it when you sense that faint glimmer in another person, when they get what you're saying. And in that instant, they glimpse the love and devotion you have for your field, the love that lead you to grad school in the first place.

And that moment makes it all worth it.

Wednesday, January 25, 2006

hello world

Hi. I'm a grad student (doctorate, music), and I'm a geek (video game, computer). My qualifying exams are looming, and I'm freaking out accordingly. So what do I do? I start a blog!

Who am I? I grew up in the Midwest, and completed my BA at a small, private, liberal arts college. Then I moved to one of the coasts, where I completed my Master's at a small performing arts school. Then I moved up the coast a bit to work on my doctorate.

What am I? I'm a composer. Yes, we exist. I did mainly instrumental music in the past, but now I'm into computer music. Instead of staff paper, I use a text editor (vim) and a LISP compiler with a few music-specific libraries. One reason for the shift is practicality: performers are hard to come by. I love the communion that happens between a composer and performers in instrumental music--that point at which you understand them, and they understand you in a deep and loving way--but opportunities to write for humans aren't always there. And computers allow me to do things musically--like explore weird tunings--that I'd never ask a musician to do.

What will I write about? You can safely assume the Ivory Tower. There will also creep in things about the arts, and probably video games (a hobby and a research interest). And...there may be some surprises along the way.