So awhile ago I wrote a post in response to some nasty criticism of the show, Doctor Who, on the Daily Breakfast podcast. (I used to listen to said podcast religiously, but just got out of the habit.) The podcast link in the original post got changed when they changed their database. The correct link to the response in the podcast that provoked my rant on Doctor Who and Catholic social justice is here.
Now there will be spoilers. If you aren't current on Doctor Who to the episode that aired yesterday ("Planet of the Ood") or last season and you don't want things spoiled, you really don't want to read any further.
Still here? Sure? There are gonna be spoilers. Big ones.
Last chance.
I mean it.
So. The criticism was that it wasn't a good "family" show because of a five second kiss between Captain Jack and the Doctor. Now, this was the most unsexy kiss ever in the franchise. The characters were, in all likelihood, going to their deaths at the tentacles of daleks. If you want sexy kisses, go watch Torchwood.
Time after time (pardon the pun), there are strong pro-life themes in Doctor Who, and I'm not just talking about what passes as "pro-life" in some circles. For instance, in the weakest of the episodes in season 3, the Doctor offers to help save the daleks at the end of "Evolution of the Daleks," a race that almost wiped out his. Then at the end of "Partners in Crime," the Doctor makes the statement about the alien Adipose children that they're just kids and can't help where they come from. (They come from people's fat and were harvested off of humans.) In "Planet of the Ood," the Doctor and Donna (who I think seriously rocks as a companion) save a race from slavery (the Ood's situation echoing the Holocaust or Exodus--ironic, since it aired yesterday, during Passover.) Not to mention in the same episode a line by the Doctor snarking at humans in our century for the use of slave labor in clothing. (At which Donna snarks back, asking if he takes humans along to feel morally superior. She injects a lot of humility into the show.)
And did I mention the fact that an ongoing theme of the series is that violence never solves anything? The times when violence is used, it backfires miserably at the Doctor. ("Resurrection of the Daleks" or the ongoing story arc relating to the destruction of his planet at the end of the Time War.) And if Doctor Who isn't a good family show, then I guess it doesn't matter that the Doctor defeats the Master (a long-term nemesis from the Jon Pertwee years) by forgiving him.
The times in which someone dies, or someone gets punished, it's usually because there's no other alternative. The Family in "Human Nature" gets punished in such a way that they can't ever harm others. The Racnoss were offered a chance to live somewhere else peacefully, but brought destruction upon themselves (see also violence causing violence.) In every case I can think of since the series restarted in 2005, the Doctor either gives the bad guys a chance to leave or he offers to help them.
(As an aside, I subscribe to the view of the Time Lords in the Big Finish Audios: they aren't corrupt bureaucrats, but more evolved beings, who're a lot like Tolkien's elves: world-weary and just want to be left alone by lesser-evolved races. In the Big Finish Audios, they're mostly peaceful, do hold life to be sacred, but also are forced into making extremely difficult decisions--even at the sacrifice of their own lives--to keep time lines intact.)
My sci-fi heroes uphold Catholic social justice. How cool is that? (I'd love to see an episode with Dorothy Day or Pierre Teilhard de Chardin--would be a good excuse to have a period episode in 1920's China. I think an encounter with the Doctor would explain a lot of the trippiness and cosmic orientation of a lot of Teilhard's writings.)
Sunday, April 20, 2008
Posted by
Garpu
at
10:16 PM
|
Labels: doctor who fanwank
Thursday, November 15, 2007
From Paul Cornell's blog. Too good not to share.
Posted by
Garpu
at
1:32 PM
|
Labels: doctor who fanwank
Friday, June 29, 2007
Mega-spoilers for Doctor Who. I mean it. Don't read this post if you don't want season 3/29 spoiled!
This is your last warning. If you don't want things spoiled, don't read behind the link. OK, I may talk about Torchwood a bit, too. This has got to be the best season of Doctor Who ever. If you'd like to learn how to make these text cuts for your very own blog, check out this help article here. No clue why the tags are appearing before the spoiler cut, but there you go.
OK. Anyone else notice how this season of Doctor Who with the last episode of Torchwood follows the Revelation of St. John almost perfectly? There's still one episode left to go, but the similarities are uncanny. All biblical quotes are taken from the New Jerusalem Bible because that's what I've got lying around. Just some scattered thoughts I have:
The fifth trumpet and Abbadon has been pointed out about the last episode of Torchwood. That's when Jack and the Doctor meet back up.
Woman clothed with the sun/Martha: 12:1-6, she escapes to the desert and is the key to the dragon's downfall. (Think we'll see more of this tomorrow.)
Jack: "...people will long for death and not find it anywhere; they will want to die and death will evade them." (5:6)
Chapter 6: kind of describes the decimation (literal) at the end of "Sound of Drums": "the sky disappeared like a scroll rolling up and all the mountains and islands were shaken from their places." Paradox machine and when the sky split and the toclafane came? On the decimation of humanity: "Immediately I saw another horse appear, deathly pale, and its rider was called Death, and Hades followed at its heels. They were given authority over a quarter of the earth, to kill by the sword, by famine, by plague and through wild beasts."
I'm really seeing the Doctor as St. Michael lately. He's been described as a lonely angel, and it's kind of his job to protect people, the universe. It sort of fits that the dragon would be the Master--he's a fallen angel, he and his armies fight against St. Michael and company. "Sound of Drums" really set up the Master as a perversion of everything the Doctor stands for, including his relationship with others.
We'll see how tomorrow's episode changes everything.
Posted by
Garpu
at
12:34 PM
|
Labels: doctor who fanwank
Sunday, April 08, 2007
1.) Life and dignity of the human person. And alien for the Doctor. When has this (from the USCCB) not been true? "We believe that every person is precious, that people are more important than things, and that the measure of every institution is whether it threatens or enhances the life and dignity of the human person." That's been the show's refrain since it started. Like in last night's episode with the Doctor's interaction with the mentally ill people in the hospital. And if "New Earth" didn't echo this theme, I don't know what does.Fair warning. There may be spoilers in this one. So it's no secret I'm a "Doctor Who" fan. I've watched the show ever since I could remember. The first episode I saw was "The Seeds of Doom," and it scared the living hell out of me. I was hooked ever since. (This was back when the Chicago PBS station, WTTW, played them in the afternoon...at least I think it was the afternoon.) I have just about every episode that's been broadcast--including "Shada"--except for some of the William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton episodes.
So I'm also a fan of the Daily Breakfast podcast. The guy who does it is a priest, who's a total geek. Fr. Roederick has been discussing "Doctor Who" lately. (He's also a fan.) So some guy came on, giving feedback about how horrible the new seasons are. First off, Captain Jack isn't all that important to the series. Second of all, he complains about how there's no organization in the universe--there never was in the Doctor Who universe--and that there's no spiritual side (I guess he missed the episode in last year's series, where the Doctor defeats Satan.)
But I'm so fed up with fanatics thinking that the only social issues that matter are homosexuality and abortion. If the guy who gave feedback on "Daily Breakfast" thought the entire first series was about "perversion," then he missed the point. Jack does kiss the Doctor, but he also kisses Rose--that's during the episode where they thought they were going to die. There wasn't anything sexual about it. If anything, I thought it was a beautiful scene. The first series (season 27 to the old fans) is really all about redemption and reconciliation. See also: "Planet of the Spiders," where the 3rd Doctor regenerates into the 4th Doctor. The guy giving feedback also says that the Doctor genocided his own people. That line was given in the same episode as "The Satan Pit," by an alien thought of to be Satan, aka "The father of all liars." The creature lied about Rose in the same episode. Why is anything else it said true? Or true in a way that doesn't twist what really happened? All we have is a PTSD-suffering alien's take on it and an evil being's. Neither are reliable informants about the Time War.
But it's just one guy's opinion from Oklahoma. His voice isn't that of other Catholics in the US. Frankly I think the Doctor does a good job of working according to Catholic social teaching. For the sake of argument, I'm using this from the USCCB, the seven key themes of Catholic social teaching.
3.) Rights and Responsibilities. Society can only be healthy when all rights are respected. I don't think this has ever not been a theme of "Doctor Who." I can't count the number of episodes in which he's fought against some dictator. Duty to society? Sure, the Doctor's not overly fond of small-scale responsibility, but given the number of times he's saved Earth and/or the universe, I think we can safely say he's got some responsibility to society.
4.) Option for the Poor and Vulnerable Again, when has this not been the case for the Doctor? I can't think of an episode where he didn't protect the poor and vulnerable.5.) The Dignity of Work and the Rights of Workers Fair labor doesn't come up much, but there have been episodes dealing with slavery and forced labor. ("Impossible Planet," "Destiny of the Daleks")
6.) Solidarity Oh yeah like the theme that we're all one race under God's creation doesn't come up. That is, that we're worthy of respect regardless of race, nationality, religion, economic status, or species.
7.) Care for God’s Creation There's been a lot of shows with environmental themes. "Sea Devils," most notably.
End of rant. Go watch "Doctor Who."
Posted by
Garpu
at
3:57 PM
|
Labels: doctor who fanwank