Showing posts with label metaphysics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label metaphysics. Show all posts

Friday, June 01, 2007

At some point words become frail. I could say so much about what I'm doing as a composer, yet nothing but silence would come close to that by which I'm confronted in the act of composition. I could fill reams of program notes about formal method and procedures, but never be able to describe the terrifying (awe-inspiring) intimacy of the moment that music gets written.

I think why so many composers in computer music hide behind technology is because without an instrumentalist to be shielded by, they're completely exposed. Every fault and failing is blasted to the world. Elements of themselves, which may or may not exist, are splayed for all to see and consume or vomit back in disgust. Real intimacy with one person you know well is scary enough. With people one doesn't know? Horrifying.

Walking along the main street by my studio, words and actions become raw. The suffering of panhandlers contrasts the bacchanalia of fraternities and sororities. Mundane errands, lunch-seekers, and drug-pushers collide. Their humanity is too much. Nothing I can actively do will fill the gaping void formed from everyday life.

This is not the place prepared for me. A composer's music, a contemplative's prayer (if the two were ever separate), this is the bread of my life for others and my vocation. If, as critics of contemporary music alledge, we only write music to be ellitist, then if not for others, why would we expose ourselves (lovingly) in such a vulnerable way?

Receive, O Lord, this all-embracing host which your whole creation, moved by your magnetism, offers you at this dawn of a new day. This bread, our toil, is of itself, I know, but an immense fragmentation; this wine, our pain is no more, I know, than a draught that dissolves. Yet in the very depths this formless mass you have implanted--and this I am sure of, for I sense it--a desire, irresistible, hallowing, which makes us cry out, believer and unbeliever alike: 'Lord make us one. Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, "Mass on the World"



Friday, March 16, 2007

An update of the dissertation meter (in seconds):

Zokutou word meterZokutou word meterZokutou word meter
705 / 4,500
(15.0%)

I keep going back and forth about whether or not I should talk about the metaphor behind the piece--the mysteries of the rosary. On the one hand, (from gender theory) there are some things that need to be reclaimed--Latin, the rosary, etc. On the other hand, I'm going to get blamed for everything bad that's happened in the past 2000 years, by virtue of being a member of that group. (Never mind that ad hominem is always a logical fallacy.) I guess if a hiring committee ascribes political beliefs to me that I don't personally hold it's not my problem (and illegal.) I know I can't get away with making some sort of political statement with this piece, so it might as well be the one I intend.

I really wish more than just the uptown/downtown crowd blogged on music. I'm getting weary of reading their glorified pissing contests. The 1970's are over, people. If you have a Ph.D,it doesn't mean you write good music. If you don't have a Ph.D, it doesn't mean you write good music. I think the one thing we can say with any certainty is that a person will (at some point in his/her life) write good music. He/She will also write really lousy music.

Another reason why I probably should discuss the ideology in my dissertation piece (pieces, really) is because those with any kind of metaphysics aren't getting much exposure. I get so tired reading blogs like new music box, and have everything be about the surface, making money, and whether or not pop music should be used in classical/new/postmodernist/whatever music. If this world and ontology is all there is, it would be a pretty depressing place to live.

I think that's why I like the music theory as model of musical experience people (Boretz, Randall, Barkin, Rahn, et al.) When you deal with theory as a model of experience, there are multiple possible takes on a given piece. It also lets the music exist as it is, in all its power. Plus pissing contests, like what exist on some new music blogs, aren't as important. We're all seeing a small piece of something complex (and ultimately beyond us). Diversity of opinion can't be a bad thing, in that case.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

On suffering

I remember being told when I was young to "offer it up," where "it" was anything burdensome, tiresome, annoying, or just plain something I didn't want to deal with. I suspect more than a few Catholics of my age heard something similar from their relatives. A number of blog posts recently have dealt with suffering, and it's a difficult notion. At one extreme, you get Girard. At the other, suffering becomes some sort of quasi-erotic fetish. Add into this the message of countless antidepressant ads that any lack of happiness is bad, one begins to wonder if there's any value at all in suffering.

I don't disagree with the bit from Von Balthasar about suffering over on Mark Mossa's blog. Our failings do cause brokenness, and the effects of our sins cause suffering. But the notion that suffering is given out of the loving concern for a divine Parent is something that sticks in my throat. No parent likes disciplining their children (of the good parents I know), but I don't know if it's out of duty--it's the parents' jobs to protect their children, and that includes providing discipline--or out of love. But sometimes suffering doesn't have a cause--people come down with horrible illnesses, people cause other people to suffer, and things happen through no fault of the person hit with whatever is causing them to suffer. This model makes me queasy because not everything that happens is a direct result of our actions, and it would be a horrible God that would punish us willy-nilly for things we didn't deserve. This smacks of abuse.

So stuff happens, and we suffer. Thing is, I think we need it. I'm not talking wallowing in one's misery, getting off on it, or a chemical imbalance. All of these are an addiction to suffering, and I think such an addiction leads to depression, which is getting stuck in one big feedback cycle. The key is that suffering can be cathartic--it leads to a healing of a relationship (as in the case of sin), or it leads to another's relief.

I think the issue of suffering is easier to understand through the arts. Granted a "sad" piece of music may not necessarily be "sad," and it probably doesn't reflect the composer's emotions, either. (Great discussion of the person and the piece in composition here.) But through its abstraction, whatever is expressed in the piece is presented so that others may experience and deal with it in a productive manner. Perhaps I'm skirting too closely to Girard again, but I think the end result is fundamentally different. Instead of sacrificial crisis, I think the key is in empathy and compassion (literally feeling with) other people.

Just saying "be happy!" and repressing unhappy thoughts and feelings isn't true happiness--you see this in the Psalms, where the mood swings wildly from utter dejection to praise, sometimes within the same psalm. I think 142 is a good example of this. In the old Benedictine office, which is closest to the plan Benedict laid out in his Rule, it lands on Saturday at Lauds. Sunday, being the "little Easter" (bringing to mind the Easter sacrifice through the Eucharist) can't happen without a little Lent (Friday), and then the nothingness of Holy Saturday. Psalm 142 calls out of this emptiness. You can't have resurrection without death, and you can't have Easter without Lent. Without true repentance, joy rings hollow.

3/14 Edited to fix the fact that psalm 142 doesn't happen on Sunday in the old Benedictine Office...


Tuesday, February 27, 2007

"Or a dream that will fade and fall apart..."

I found my jazz recordings today. They were shoved away in a box, plastic dusty and liner notes faded, as if they belonged to someone else. I couldn't listen to them until now. The grief was too new.

Growing up as a violinist, you don't get many opportunities to play jazz. The orchestra teacher doubled as the jazz band teacher, since budgets were getting cut every year for arts. Since I couldn't play it, I listened. During college, I started playing in jazz combos. Improvisation unlocked a forgotten floodgate--composition--and my first piece (a little jazz waltz) terrified me. But composing for jazz ensembles--my real love--was frustrating (I didn't want to play it, although I enjoyed it; and jazz musicians can be the epitome of stubborn, when it comes to new ideas--things existing classical music for the past few decades.) I took a chance at a classical composition department--my Master's--and they took a chance on me. I hadn't listened to or written jazz since then.

Constant discouragement and fighting took its toll. Once I left my undergraduate school I was too burned out on the violin to keep playing, and jazz was an unfortunate casualty. Busy in my new world as a "classical" composer, I tucked away my jazz compact discs, instead discovering Lou Harrison, Colin McPhee, Earle Brown, Morton Feldman, Ligeti, Berio...

But these old recordings--their music as familiar to me as my fiancé's face--never left me. Everything I am today as a composer existed then--I learned to orchestrate from Billy Strayhorn and Gil Evans; the serialism in Miles Davis' album, "Aura," was my own because I didn't know the right way to write serial music; the sheer walls of raw ecstasy and timbre of late 'Trane; the displaced canonic metrics of Pat Motian and Bill Frisell, the wordless poetry of Kenny Wheeler's "Music for Large and Small Ensembles, the counterpoint in the microcosm of jazz voicing--these are my roots.

If you truly love something, it's so much a part of you that a little time, dust, or absence isn't permanent, an old friend you run into after decades of silence. After a little awkward silence, you find out they never went away.

(Whoever emails me with the correct standard the title comes from will get a surprise...you may have to bug me to mail it, though.)

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

Deliverance

There are moments when the Divine Office is oddly resonant. Thanks to Rev. Mommy's postings of her morning and evening prayer and finding a copy of the Benedictine office, I've gotten back in the habit. Tonight's psalms at vespers were one of those odd moments, when it seems to leap up and speak to your situation.

"Circumdederunt me dolores mortis:
et pericula inferni invenerunt me.
Tribulationem et dolorem inveni:
et nomen Domini invocavi.
O Domine, libera animam meam:
misericors Dominus, et justus, et Deus noster miseretur.
Custodiens parvulos Dominus:
humiliatus sum, et liberavit me.
Convertere, anima mea, in requiem tuam:
quia Dominus benefecit tibi.
Quia eripuit animam meam de morte:
oculos meos a lacrimis, pedes meos a lapsu.
Placebo Domino in regione vivorum." Psalm 114:3-9
I've been working on the dissertation, and for some reason, I was thinking of how my situation was back in college. For many, college is a time where one flowers and discovers the things which form one's vocation. My time as an undergrad was no exception: I discovered that I could compose music and I discovered the Rule of St. Benedict.

At first I was quiet about both of them. I composed music in middle and high school and was forbidden to do so, since it took time away from the violin. Composing was considered a further waste of time in college. My interest in the Rule of St. Benedict was similarly not something to be encouraged: my parents had left the Catholic Church shortly after my first Communion, and they had an irrational fear of my being alone, that I would crack for being "too cloistered." Getting into CalArts for composition seemed like a miracle come true. I didn't know how things were going to work out, but it felt like someone was looking out for me.

My relationship with the Rule of St. Benedict and my process of becoming an Oblate was another story. To say there was resistance was an understatement. When I was to become an oblate novice, there was no way I could've gotten to the monastery where I would've been affiliated. I was imprisoned at my mom's for that summer, since she refused to let me take the car anywhere (I couldn't afford my own), nor would she take me anywhere. There was no public transit between the towns in south-central Illinois. My interest in Benedictine monasticism was met with ridicule (to the point of cruelty), and whatever I did (Divine Office, lectio) had to be hidden. By the end of that summer, I had memorized most of the psalms. That way if my books were taken from me, I'd have some semblance of the liturgy.

"For He has delivered my soul from death; my eyes from tears; and my feet from failing. I will please God in the land of the living."

Thinking back to how things were, I'm overwhelmed by the fact that I can both compose and recite the Divine Office openly. I don't have to hide my composerly or contemplative dimensions. I don't have to live with the false fear that my mental health will suffer for being who I was called to be.

"Turn, my soul, to your rest; for the Lord has been good to you."

Tuesday, January 16, 2007

"For the use of..."

So while drinking theraflu (head cold) and watching bad daytime TV (what else do you do with a head cold?), I'm catching up on my blogs. I found this entry about poverty over at A Nun's Life. Sr. Julie writes:

When I asked a sister about why they say “for the use of” she said that no one of us owns a single thing in the congregation — even that prayer book that we’ve used for years and which bears the marks of our praying hands and of our tears. By the simple act of writing “for the use of” a sister recognizes that she truly does not own a thing and that all she has is gift. A sister recognizes that if one of her sisters needed that prayer book, she would give it to her in a heartbeat.
Her discussion of poverty and ownership reminded me of knowledge--in a sense, it isn't really mine. It was entrusted to me by someone else, and I'm only using it, until I pass it off to future students. In a sense that which I'm learning about now is only "for the use of Jen" until such time that it's time for me to give it away to someone else.

In another blog, I found this post. Now I don't doubt that some cloning as composition teaching went on in generations before me, but I've never personally experienced it. I've never felt pressured into adopting one style over another. If a teacher played another person's music for me, it was because the piece was interesting or that it was something the teacher wanted to share, not because it was something I should emulate. Perhaps the piece represented a possible solution to a problem I had in a piece. Maybe it was just something cool. Most of my teachers have been pretty quiet on the subject of their own music--which in retrospect is a shame because I can't think of a teacher I've had who doesn't write good music.

I was warned when I was applying for my doctorate that it would ruin me, that I'd not encounter good music, and that those who get doctorates aren't good composers. The first three haven't been true, and as to the last one, I know plenty of people who write horrible music and don't have a last bit of alphabet soup after their names. I think that's the one, great equalizer of academics and non-academics--we all write bad music now and then.

I think my teachers have all instinctively embodied Sr. Julie's understanding of poverty--that the knowledge we have isn't really ours, and should be willingly given up to those who need it. Our knowledge is a gift, and to pass it on is the greatest tribute we could possibly give to those who gave it to us in the first place. Maybe those who worry about the loss of a voice or creativity never really had it in the first place.